Devolo house manage evaluation part 3 – security & safety
welcome to the third instalment of our evaluation of the Devolo house manage range. So far we have the starter pack up running with some extra movement detection as well as changing capabilities.
We have tested lots of elements of the myDevolo app, adding devices, producing groups, rules as well as scenes. We will now look at the security as well as safety applications in addition to further software application capabilities.
One of the justifications for building a wise house is security as well as safety in addition to comfort as well as energy efficiency. With the utilize of rules, groups as well as scenes it’s extremely simple to provide the appearance that your residential property is occupied while you are away by turning lights as well as even appliances like a TV on as well as off, however a lot more can be achieved.
Safety
The Devolo Smoke Detector (Art No:09504) RRP £49.99 operates as a stand alone smoke detector. When it detects smoke it emits a loud alerting tone by means of its piezo electric sounder as well as flashes the centre LED switch just like a routine battery powered detector. Its style indicates you have to put a battery in it before you can screw it up, we have seen headlines of a terminate in a residential property that had a smoke alarm however no battery in it. eliminate it from its base for as well long as well as the alarm will go off, just like a tamper alarm. regrettable it doesn’t comments the tamper condition to the software.
Anyone who has checked out one of the previous evaluations will understand what’s coming – adding gadgets to the Devolo network takes seconds. begin the add gadgets sequence, tell it which gadget you want to add, press a button as well as there you go.
Once linked to the Z-Wave network it’s capabilities are improved further. It can be integrated with the rest of the network, triggering lights to find on as well as send notifications by means of sms or email when an alarm is triggered with the proper set of rules as well as notifications.
Current UK building regulations stipulate amongst other things that, a house must have at least one smoke detector on every floor, within 7.5m of each door, long-term AC mains powered, on their own circuit linked back to the consumer system as well as be interlinked so when one goes off they all go off. With these demands in mind this detector like lots of on the market with a battery power supply will not satisfy building regulations as well as might only be utilized to compliment an existing compliant smoke detector installation. It is a completely great smoke detector for retrofitting or for utilize in conjunction with an existing system.
We tried to set up a policy to ensure that when a smoke alarm was triggered that one more detector would noise in tandem however the app does not enable you to put the smoke detector in the ‘Then’ part of the rules builder. I am sure Devolo have their reasons however it would be great to trigger all smoke detectors if one goes off in a similar method to hardwired as well as interlinked detectors work.
It would likewise be beneficial if the sounder of the smoke detector might be utilized a part of an alarm setup. set the system to an ‘away’ or ‘night’ mode as well as if any type of of the proper alarm sensors are triggered then the sounders emit a different alerting tone to the one utilized in the event of a smoke alarm trigger. At present you requirement to get an extra sounder.
After at first setting up this gadget as well as before publishing Devolo issued a recall of the smoke detector as it has shown formal deficiencies with regard to European common EN14604. For this reason as well as as a precautionary determine they issued a recall. We were provided an RMA number as well as prepaid postage. A replacement will be issued between July as well as August, so no precise date.
Security
The system has remove safety applications as it can find movement in addition to opening doors as well as windows. The Devolo platform does appear dependable sufficient as so far it does whatever when we expect it would. There are some missing features when compared to an existing or standard alarm system as well as this can be stated for the majority of Z-Wave devices. The test home has a traditional intruder alarm as well as we believed to compare as well as contrast the two.
As mentioned in an earlier evaluation of the sensors there is no tamper detection. A sensor might be interfered with without any type of indication. On the test home traditional alarm removal of a sensor gadget or opening its situation will trigger an alarm.
In the event of a power cut the hub loses all performance whereas the test home alarm has a battery backup so the residential property stays secured as well as features like the auto-dialer as well as smoke detection still function. This issue may be get rid of by adding a UPS to the hub as well as Web routers as well as gateway to preserve the system as well as a connection to the outside world.
The test home has two outside siren/strobe units that will spring into life if triggered by the alarm. At the moment there is no similar z-wave gadget we understood about. It may be possible to integrate these by utilizing a z-wave based low voltage relay as well as an input appropriate for the outside unit.
The intruder alarm market requirements are set in documents PD6662 as well as EN50131. These govern the technical demands for the design, installation as well as operation of alarm systems as well as their components. We have not come across any type of Z-Wave elements that satisfy these standards.
The expense of Z-Wave gadgets compared to standard wired or even wireless elements is higher. For comparison a quick browse will turn up a Yale diy wireless alarm with a telecommunication feature, bell box, dummy bell box, two PIR, two door contacts for £195 as well as adding a crucial fob, PIR or one more door/window switch will expense £20 not they normal Z-Wave £50 device. Of program this is a stand alone system as well as you would be not able to leverage any type of type of house automation with it. A similar wired system from a trusted maker costs even less. The test home has PIRs in every space as well as several door as well as window sensors. Some convergence in these technologies as well as requirements will occur shortly, one imminent example is the Texecom link system which will enable a traditional safety system to work with Z-Wave based components. We will have to wait to see what this indicates for the house automation market.
Any Z-Wave safety application must be referred to as a comfort rather than a replacement for a standard system particularly where mandated by insurance coverage business or where you would want to take a discount rate on your house insurance coverage policy as a result of having a system installed as well as maintained.
Notifications
You have a option of notification methods, SMS, email or push as well as you can set up one or several methods. You can utilize the Devolo SMS gateway however you will be restricted to the number of SMS you can send as well as a journal of messages sent can be accessed with your profile settings. It’s not evident exactly how to get a larger SMS entitlement so we utilized the on the internet concern tool however no different to previous events ‘No professionals were on line’. We submitted a concern as well as you requirement to add some a lot more to a cart. It’s not evident where this cart is however back on the myDevolo there is a link to ‘devolo shop’ however it is in German. You can likewise configure your own SMS gateway if you requirement to send a lot more messages or have an existing account elsewhere.
It is tough to see where to add extra email addresses for notifying other people as all the notifications are tailored to the registered individual of the system. once again we submitted a concern as well as you requirement to add a ‘Sharer’ in the my setting page. You go into an email address as well as an invite is sent to the new user. The new individual needs to go into their name as well as date of birth as well as agree to the normal terms as well as conditions. up until the individual registers they will show as pending on under the listing of sharers. There is no evident method to add extra smart phone numbers or register extra devices.
Once a notification is configuration you next go to rules as well as configuration a policy to trigger a notification, for example email the residential property owner when the front door is opened.
Further experience of the app
One element to note is what appears to be the prolonged process to get to the info you requirement in the app. To illustrate, preliminary starting the app you are satisfied with a Devolo sprinkle screen, complied with by a myDevolo screen where you choose HomeControl, then on the next screen you choose your HomeControl Hub as well as then you see your devices. Our experience is this can take between 20-30 seconds. a few of this will be because of gadget as well as Web latency however we believe Devolo might eliminate a couple of the steps explained above.
The app appears to be a shell for a webpage particularly created for the little screen as the exact same pages can be viewed in a desktop browser. When moving from one screen to one more you often see a ‘Loading’ spinner as well as when going into a gadget an preliminary message flashes up ‘No widgets available! Please add widgets to the dashboard.’ Whilst disconcerting it swiftly vanishes when a spinner has rotated.
On the app it is not possible to gain access to the history graphs, a function we believe is missing. It’s most likely finest to explain the app as a fundamental customer of the system as you have restricted configuration or editing functionality, for example you can on turn on/off an existingnotification, you cannot set up a new one, you requirement to revert back to your desktop browser.
Device latency
Having utilized the a few of the gadgets for a long time one inescapable element is the latency. This is noticeable at night when the movement sensor is triggered to when the light comes on. It may only be a fractions of a second however it seems like much longer as you wait on the light to find on in a dark hallway once again there may be factors outside the systems manage such as regional network as well as Web traffic.
Key Fob
The second piece of hardware we will look at in this instalment is the remote crucial fob (Art No: 9506 RRP £35). It’s a 4 button gadget no bigger than your normal garage door remote. Each of the 4 buttons can be programmed separately as well as you have several manage choices, direct gadget manage or trigger scenes.
In our test home we utilized it to turn on the lights as a welcome house as well as to turn off the lights on the method out or going to bed.
It is possible to see exactly how this might discover further utilizes with some extra hardware such as a low voltage relay, it might open electric gates as well as garage doors. regrettably Devolo have not added this ability to their hardware portfolio however it is offered from other manufacturers.
Battery Life
It’s been 7 weeks considering that we installed the door sensor as well as the movement sensor, we are delighted to state the battery life is reported as 100%. thinking about these are in the busiest part of the test home this is a appealing start. We will keep a track of this in our future instalments.
In summary
The Smoke Detector has some technical conformity problems to resolve which Devolo have in hand. regrettably it is no replacement for your difficult wired smoke detector. The inability to utilize it as an independent sounder or to utilize rules to trigger other detectors limits its flexibility.
It’s a similar story with security, a Devolo system will not replace your existing alarm system as well as we believe this is true of the huge majority of Z-Wave gadgets as well as not just Devolo. The system may provide you some extra remote exposure or reassurance as well as manage of illumination when away from house however you requirement to program this. A excellent addition would be ‘holiday mode’ where the system would randomly switch different lights on as well as off to provide the understanding somebody is at home.
The crucial fob has great deals of possibilities when integrated with scenes, or other pieces of hardware. It has a excellent range, far much better than the test home remote garage door or entrance remote, so it would be worth checking out the genuine world interfaces such as the Z-Wave Fortrezz Interface/Bridge Module MIMOlite.
There are areas of the software application that are just not intuitive sufficient though as well as without any online chat as well as lack of tutorials/instructions it can make the individual experience frustrating at times. It is great to see the FAQ is now offered in English whereas it was in German in our very first review.
#
Preview
Product
Rating
Price
1
Devolo house manage flood / Water Sensor
28 Reviews
£16.38
get on Amazon
2
Devolo house manage Starter pack – smart house for all, white, silver, 9361
22 Reviews
£89.95
get on Amazon